Differences Between a Coach and Consultant Approach to Career Assessments
Below is a chart that depicts the differences between a coach and consultant approach to the selection, administration, and review of assessments with a client. I encourage you to adopt the consultant approach in order for your clients’ learning to be enhanced which in turn will lead to their motivated actions.
Copyright 2005-2010. Nancy Branton, PCC, M. A.
| COACH-APPROACH | CONSULTANT-APPROACH | |
| Assessment Choice |
Explores with client which assessment to use and for what purpose. | Determines which assessment will be used and for what purpose. |
| Confidentiality |
Client’s assessment results are held confidential. | Client’s assessment results may or may not be held confidential |
| Delivery of Report | Shares report with client in advance of the session. | Waits to share the report until the start of the session. |
| Session Check-In | Asks client what it was like to take the assessment and explores his/her reactions to it. | Thanks client for completing the assessment and asks the client if s/he has any questions. |
| Session Focus | Asks the client what s/he wants to focus on. Allows the client to set the agenda. | Takes charge of the session’s agenda. |
| Content Delivery | Shares background information about the assessment with the client, provides a general overview of it, and asks the client which pieces of it to focus on. | Explains the content of the assessment and moves through the results in a linear fashion. |
| Accuracy of Results | Explores results and allows the client to determine what is (or is not) accurate for him/her. | Assumes the results are mostly accurate. |
| Client Observation | Observes client’s nonverbal behavior and tone of voice. Draws out the client through use of active listening and powerful questions | Observes client to ensure what’s being shared is understood. |
| Opinions & Judgments | Explores client’s resistance to results and never makes the client wrong. | Shares opinions with the client about his/her results. |
| Client Awareness | Asks client what key insights s/he learned from the assessment. Recognizes that awareness is a process. | Assumes the client will learn from the assessment results and works to make the client fully aware of them. |
| Development Focus (if applicable) | Asks the client which areas s/he wants to be the focus his/her career development on. | Suggests to client which areas to focus his/her career development on. |
| Actions to Take | Asks the client what steps s/he wants to take first. | Suggests actions to the client. |
| Accountability | Asks the client what works best for him/her in terms of accountability. | Summarizes which actions the client will take. |
